Should be pretty easy to detect what is wrong. Simply switch to Charon, re-configure it to use "external judge", delete all judges that came with it, copy & paste all of the azenv judges contained in Lorissa's well maintained list at DCSproxy.com, test them and use the fastest (lowest ping score), and report your status then.
By report your status, indicate the judge used and post at least 100 of the proxies tested.